Atlantic Acting School produces several full length plays each year, ranging from Shakespeare to modern works. Casts for these plays include the Atlantic's third-year NYU students and Atlantic Conservatory students in their fifth semester. Recent past productions include As You Like It, Twelfth Night, The Winter's Tale, The Visit, Hot L Baltimore, The Children's Hour, Rimers of Eldridge and Mad Forest.

The School also produces several evenings of one-act plays each year for students at an earlier point in their training.

Alumni of the school are eligible to audition for Atlantic for Kids productions, which are performed on the Atlantic mainstage.